If A sends an email to B to tell on C, but there is no evidence against C etc. Can B sue A on any grounds?

Answer :

  • http://legalhelp.com.sg/cache/img/201301/no-image.76x72.crop.jpg


    answered on 15/05/2018

    flag as inappropriate

    B likely cannot sue A. 

    However, C may be able to sue A depending on the contents of the email. 

    First, C may claim against A under the tort of defamation (specifically libel)  provided the elements of defamation can be proven: generally, the statement must harm the reputation of the victim, the statement must refer to the victim, and must have been communicated to a third party (B in this case). There are defences available such as fair comment and justification. Additionally, defamation is a criminal offence under section 499 of the Penal Code. 

    Second, C may also claim against A for malicious falsehood if A has maliciously made false representations with a view to injuring A's goodwill or economic reputation. C would have to prove that he/she has suffered loss as a result, such as loss of sales.

    Third, C may be able to sue A under the economic tort of inducing breach of contract if B has breached a contractual obligation owed to A as a result of the email. Specifically, it must be proven that A knows of an existing contractual relationship between B and C, and that A has intended the breach of the obligation. The email must be a direct and effective cause of B's breach, and damage must have resulted from the breach of contract.

    Did you find this post useful? Please provide your feedback by clicking on the link above.